When does Autopark and Summon show up in Germany

EdinEPTX

Member
Apr 21, 2024
90
54
18
i am a little confused, Summon with all derivates was working with sensors correct. Now after Tesla changed it to optical view it was told it is not allowed due to country based legislation. I was told recently BMW can do in the new i5 series a similar technology... Why is it allowed for BMW and Tesla got restrictions? This cause some questioning to me...
The EU is scared that a US based company will leapfrog the legacy auto makers over there.
 

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
i am a little confused, Summon with all derivates was working with sensors correct. Now after Tesla changed it to optical view it was told it is not allowed due to country based legislation. I was told recently BMW can do in the new i5 series a similar technology... Why is it allowed for BMW and Tesla got restrictions? This cause some questioning to me...
Probably because BMW uses a hybrid solution, USSs + Vision. USSs are more reliable than vision, full stop. They detect what vision just cannot.
 

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
2024.20.6 releases Autopark out side of America, can anyone confirm whether it works in the UK on EAP Non USS car
Seems like you're getting it this time! It's marked as available to Italy also for non-USS vehicles, although I updated just today to 20.3 and don't have EAP/FSD to fully confirm. I might be thinking of adding FSD if I start to see some actual benefit picking up, however I don't see EAP worth the price, with or without autopark, unless I see a hint of FSD within a year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: joe_apxc

joe_apxc

Member
Feb 20, 2024
87
47
18
I was surprised seeing this in the release notes, as it was already working (at least sometimes) for me. Update installed, i will test it tomorrow. Lets see what its capable of now, i guess its the Updated version of Autopark.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K.I.T.T.

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
I was surprised seeing this in the release notes, as it was already working (at least sometimes) for me. Update installed, i will test it tomorrow. Lets see what its capable of now, i guess its the Updated version of Autopark.
If it was already working, you might be in for a disappointment. It should be just an extension to 3rd world countries on the Tesla geopolitical map.
 

joe_apxc

Member
Feb 20, 2024
87
47
18
If it was already working, you might be in for a disappointment. It should be just an extension to 3rd world countries on the Tesla geopolitical map.
Got to test it two times before work. It now shows the new visualization of Autopark and i can choose a parking spot on the screen now. The first time i was not sure it got better, the second time worked like a charm. It behaves differently than before, thats for sure. Still not perfect on the parking lot of my workplace, but i will test other parking lots after work. So far it looks promising.
 

fbaboni

New member
Jun 28, 2024
1
0
1
Summon doesn't work in EU due to legislation.
In EU it is mandatory to have a person behind the wheels, while Summon is "driving without a driver". So that is why it is forbidden.
 

EVSteveA

Active member
Jan 19, 2023
145
49
28
To my knowledge in the uk it was active to USS vehicles Someone correct me if I am
Wrong
 

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
To my knowledge in the uk it was active to USS vehicles Someone correct me if I am
Wrong
To my knowledge it has never been active in the EU. Only autopark, until it wasn't.

That's why I've never purchased EAP/FSD, the only benefit being getting rid of obnoxious autopilot beeps (which on autopilot on are unnecessary at best) for lane-changing.
 

joe_apxc

Member
Feb 20, 2024
87
47
18
Summon doesn't work in EU due to legislation.
In EU it is mandatory to have a person behind the wheels, while Summon is "driving without a driver". So that is why it is forbidden.
Thats not quite true. I do have it working on my M3, it just has some limitations in the EU. Summon can only drive if a FOB Key or Phone with Bluetooth is in the range of 6 meters to the vehicle and you need to press a button continuously to get it working. Also, it can drive a maximum distance of 20 meters i think, before you need to manually get in the vehicle and drive it a bit to use summon again. I think its currently limited to USS Vehicles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: K.I.T.T.

Sonny1983

New member
Apr 30, 2024
9
10
3
Thats not quite true. I do have it working on my M3, it just has some limitations in the EU. Summon can only drive if a FOB Key or Phone with Bluetooth is in the range of 6 meters to the vehicle and you need to press a button continuously to get it working. Also, it can drive a maximum distance of 20 meters i think, before you need to manually get in the vehicle and drive it a bit to use summon again. I think its currently limited to USS Vehicles.
Yes, but the limitations are killing it. I live in Germany, and I never get it to work anywhere close to 6m away from the car. I basically have to stand max 1.5m (3ft) away from it or it can't read my phone key. I don't know if it's the iPhone 13 that maybe has a weak BT signal, but anyhow, fro me it's not usable. Plus, the extreme delay when pressing a button (about 5s) is a killer. If you use it to get your car out of a frequented parking lot, others will get furious before it's done. And often the car just stopps without anything beeing in the way. You also don't get feedback why it stopped.

The way this feature is advertised on the German Tesla website is misleading. The animation with the person standing at least 10m away from a garage is just unrealistic here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: joe_apxc

joe_apxc

Member
Feb 20, 2024
87
47
18
Yes, but the limitations are killing it. I live in Germany, and I never get it to work anywhere close to 6m away from the car. I basically have to stand max 1.5m (3ft) away from it or it can't read my phone key. I don't know if it's the iPhone 13 that maybe has a weak BT signal, but anyhow, fro me it's not usable. Plus, the extreme delay when pressing a button (about 5s) is a killer. If you use it to get your car out of a frequented parking lot, others will get furious before it's done. And often the car just stopps without anything beeing in the way. You also don't get feedback why it stopped.

The way this feature is advertised on the German Tesla website is misleading. The animation with the person standing at least 10m away from a garage is just unrealistic here.

That is also true, it is very limited in real world usage as you stated with the example of a busy parking lot. Takes a couple seconds to start creeping. But if you have a very narrow garage at home like me, it can still be useful to send it into the garage and summon it out of it again, i use it every day before driving to work and after getting home from work. Apart from home, i only used it once or twice in a public parking lot because other cars parked like s*it and it was the only available space. So i used summon to get it in and out of the spot. Luckily, no other driver was around so i had the time it takes to use it. I do hope they improve it by a lot, so that i can also be useful in busy parking lots because other drivers dont have any time whatsoever XD
 

Henrik

New member
Jul 26, 2023
14
0
1
News from Smart Summon world? We still wait to get the update in Germany with a working Summon and Smart Summon..., I guess Tesla will lose markets to others soon, recently I drove a BYD car and a BMW and both could do Summon. No legal discussions about no delivery of this feature and no word of restrictions and stories it will roll out in two weeks (since 2 years). I like my Tesla Modell Y but I do not like the delays in key features that I bought 2 years ago - even not a compensation for the delay is offered...
Apart of this Tesla is in the middle of the shipment problems of cars in Germany the numbers are not really performing, I guess it would help to change the route and show up with some customer friendly reaction.
 

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
BMW and BYD combine USS and Vision, that's why they can deliver what Tesla can't.
But hey, BMW and BYD don't need to train their FSD models for Mars.
Whoopsie.
 
Last edited:

Henrik

New member
Jul 26, 2023
14
0
1
Hi K.I.T.T., i agree this is maybe the case but cost discussion is not relevant to customers which bought a car with features. From what we were told in 2022 Summon was close to switch to visual system. Now it shows up as brand new development after cost reduction for the feature and no real compensation to customers. Legal situation was known even in past to Tesla☝️. Fact is a innovative company like Tesla want to be, should be listening to their poor clients, not only to cost calculations... My point is simply it's time to come up with this key feature and the correction of the FSD problems! with Version 2024.27.25, even in Germany!!!! Competitors didn´t sleep as we can see.
 

K.I.T.T.

Active member
Mar 26, 2024
266
189
43
Italy
I try to be more explicit: now that some major pieces of the puzzle are on the table, it starts to become evident that we're all guinea pigs happily training FSD for Mars, where - incidentally! - USS simply wouldn't work, hence the otherwise incomprehensible stubbornness in removing them.
Probably in the grand scheme of things for Musk it works better as it is, for the time being. Anyway, no one in their sane mind would drop a Tesla for lack of these features - yet.
When other competitors will improve significantly, we'll see what will change.
For the moment "on Planet Earth" there's no competition, except probably the Xiaomi... when SU7 will arrive to our market.
 

Henrik

New member
Jul 26, 2023
14
0
1
Hi K.I.T.T, i suggest you try the new BMW 5 series or X series, plus the new BYD which is a nice car by the way as well. Xiaomi is no dealer around me in Munich. Welcome on "Planet Earth" ;)